Just Push Play: DVD Review of ’Seraphim Falls’
PHOTOGRAPHS TO BE USED SOLELY FOR ADVERTISING, PROMOTION, PUBLICITY OR REVIEWS OF THIS SPECIFIC MOTION PICTURE AND TO REMAIN THE PROPERTY OF THE STUDIO. NOT FOR SALE OR REDISTRIBUTION.

Mike's Take: 3 Stars

After the North defeated the South, bad blood was rampant throughout the states despite all efforts to preserve our more perfect union. “Seraphin Falls” uses two characters, a Union and Confederate Soldier (played by Pierce Brosnan and Liam Neeson, respectively), to represent broad strokes of anger, despair and the futile need for revenge.

The plot is a bare-knuckle, stripped down vengeance narrative played out in breath-taking backdrops of wide open desert, perilous mountaintops and woodland surroundings. I couldn’t have cast a better pair of adversaries than Brosnan and Neeson.

The film can be excruciating slow at points, the action is long-awaited, and the resolution of conflict is ambiguous in the finale. It’s more psychological-driven — often meaning dull and not for the inattentive viewer.

Having said all that, I liked it. It’s a fine morality play on film, though a little odd in its ultimate ‘good versus evil’ theme. If you don’t expect a typical Wild West adventure, you might be surprised by “Seraphim Falls.”

Jorge’s Take: 1 1/2 Stars

I suppose we can’t expect a normal story line to conclude in a normal satisfying way any more. “Seraphim Falls” begins like a typical man-hunt drama, where the prey proves to be ever resourceful and virtually unstoppable. This hooked me. I had to see how a Civil War era version of James Bond would fall to the persistent Liam Neeson whose only motive to exist is vengeance.

Much like other man-hunt movies starring Tommy Lee Jones where the prolonged hunt takes audiences toward a grand reckoning of injustices, “Seraphim Falls” leads us to an open field for the final confrontation. But instead of one gunslinger beating the other to the draw, a third party enters the stage. An alien might as well have landed in the middle of the desert to resolve the conflict because I couldn’t figure out what to make of her. I still can’t make sense of this Twilight Zone ending, but watching Brosnan and Neeson perform together did keep me from hating this movie altogether.